Rhonda Everitt REALTOR® Call or text 513-457-1115
Share

The Economy is Growing, So Why Does that Mortgage Payment still feel Tight?

Two-story stone and gray-sided home with a two-car garage and a landscaped front lawn

The economy is growing, so why does that mortgage payment still feel tight?

If you've been house hunting in Mason, West Chester, Lebanon, or Springboro lately, you may have had this moment: you're preapproved, your job is steady, you have a real reason to move, and yet when it's time to write an offer, your gut says, "I'm just not comfortable with that payment."

Then you turn on the news and hear that the economy is booming and people are spending more. It's easy to wonder if something is wrong with you for feeling stretched.

There isn't. Both things can be true at the same time, and the latest government numbers show why.

What the October headlines left out

On October 29, the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis reported that the economy grew at a 3.4% annual rate in the third quarter, after inflation. That sounds great, and for the country as a whole, it is. But GDP measures total economic output. It doesn't measure what's left in your checking account at the end of the month.

The BEA's report on household income and spending for September, released the same day, told a different story:

  • Spending rose 0.5% in dollar terms for the month.
  • After inflation, spending was essentially flat, up less than 0.1%.
  • Inflation-adjusted take-home income fell 0.3% for the month.
  • Prices were up 3.6% from a year earlier, by the BEA's main inflation measure.

In plain English: people are spending more dollars, but those dollars aren't buying much more than before, and take-home pay isn't keeping up with prices. That's not a picture of households with extra room in their budget for a mortgage.

These are national averages, of course. Your situation is your own. But if you've been feeling the squeeze, the data backs you up.

Your raise may already be spoken for

Here's a simple example. Say your take-home pay went up $200 a month this year. Nice! But over the same stretch, your childcare, car insurance, groceries, and gas went up a combined $250 a month.

You're earning more, and you have $50 less to work with. So when someone says, "But your income went up," it doesn't really answer the question, "Can I live comfortably with this payment?"

You might also be holding money back for things a lender never asks about: a roof you know is coming due, a medical bill, a commission-based job with uneven months, or simply the peace of mind of a real emergency fund. Those are good reasons, and they count.

Remember this: a preapproval tells you how much a lender is willing to let you borrow. It doesn't tell you how much you should spend. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau makes the same point: lenders don't account for all of your household's priorities and savings goals.

As a Ramsey Trusted agent, I encourage buyers to start with what fits their life, not the top of their approval letter. Dave Ramsey's guideline is a monthly payment of no more than 25% of take-home pay on a 15-year fixed mortgage. Whatever number you land on, it should be one you can sleep with.

Figure out which part feels tight

"The payment feels too high" can mean a few different things, and each one has a different fix.

If it's the monthly cost: We can adjust your search range and look at the full picture, not just principal and interest. Property taxes vary a lot from one school district to the next here in Butler and Warren Counties, and HOA dues, insurance, and upkeep add up. Sometimes a slightly lower price in the right spot makes a big difference.

If it's the cash at closing: That's a conversation with your lender about closing costs and how much savings you'll have left afterward. Just know that a smaller upfront payment usually means a bigger monthly one, so weigh both.

If it's uncertainty about your income: It may make sense to slow down and give yourself more runway. Finding a way to qualify doesn't make the worry go away.

My job is to help you pinpoint what's really holding you back and get you in front of the right people to solve it. You decide what fits your life.

Sellers: the headlines don't set your price

If you're selling, you might be thinking, "The economy is growing. Why aren't I getting stronger offers?"

National numbers can't answer that. The answer is almost always local: what else is for sale in your price range and neighborhood, the condition of your home, how it's priced, and what the buyers shopping your segment can actually afford right now.

The economic report isn't a reason to sit tight and change nothing, and it isn't a reason to slash your price either. What helps is looking at the facts about your home: what comparable homes cost, which ones are getting offers, and what the buyers who toured yours actually said. A strong economy doesn't make every asking price work.

How to read the next headline

When you see a story saying income or spending is up, ask three quick questions:

  • Is the number adjusted for inflation?
  • What time period does it cover?
  • Does it describe the whole country, or people like you?

Those details can completely change what a headline means for your move.

Let's make sure your budget works

The national economy is the backdrop. Your household budget is what actually has to work. If you're thinking about buying or selling in the Greater Cincinnati area and want a plan that fits your real numbers, not just a headline, I'd love to help. Reach out anytime.

Rhonda Everitt, REALTOR®

Comey & Shepherd Realtors

Serving Mason, West Chester, Lebanon, Springboro, and the northern Cincinnati suburbs

Sources: U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, GDP Advance Estimate, Third Quarter 2026 (Oct. 29, 2026); U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, Personal Income and Outlays, September 2026 (Oct. 29, 2026); Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, homebuying and budgeting guidance.

More from the blog